Two Deer Run houses went under contract this fall. 617 Overhill Drive was built in 1994 and has 2,086 square feet. It went under contract at a $400,000 list price, and its listing remarks mention new carpet, a freshly painted bathroom and a renovated tile shower. 420 Middle Valley Lane was also built in 1994 and has 2,126 square feet. It went under contract at $425,000, and its remarks list new flooring, new exterior doors, a new garage door and opener, and "TWO NEW ZONED HVAC SYSTEMS!"
That is $25,000 between two houses of about the same size and age. The clearest difference in the listings is that one documents two new HVAC systems, and the other names no system updates.
The same pattern shows up across Deer Run's fall listings. The community has 848 homes, according to the Deer Run HOA's own site. Every home in this fall's listing records was built between 1993 and 1997, so each one is now 29 to 33 years old. With age roughly the same across these records, three things move the price: how big the house is, what sits below the main floor, and what a past owner has already paid to replace.
The fall records, side by side
The table lists the Deer Run homes in Georgia MLS records that closed, went under contract or were for sale as of mid-November 2026. The price per square foot is our own math from the listed price and square footage. Under-contract prices are list prices. Final sale prices may differ, and some of these may have closed by the time you read this.
| Address | Status, mid-Nov. 2026 | Built | Sq ft | Basement | Price | Per sq ft | What the remarks say was replaced |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 512 Old Field Cove | Sold 10/30/2026 | 1994 | 4,236 | Finished, full | $675,000 | $159 | Recently replaced roof, updated front windows, exterior paint |
| 373 Yonah Circle | Sold 11/09/2026 | 1996 | 2,864 | Finished, full | $490,000 | $171 | "NEW ROOF!" |
| 376 Yonah Circle | Under contract | 1996 | 3,960 | Finished | $544,000 | $137 | Low-E windows, architectural roof, added attic insulation |
| 4035 Dream Catcher Dr. | Under contract | 1993 | 2,261 | None | $475,000 | $210 | One-owner home, plantation shutters |
| 420 Middle Valley Ln. | Under contract | 1994 | 2,126 | Unfinished, full | $425,000 | $200 | Two new zoned HVAC systems, new doors |
| 617 Overhill Dr. | Under contract | 1994 | 2,086 | Finished, partial | $400,000 | $192 | New carpet, renovated shower |
| 4101 Dream Catcher Dr. | Active | 1997 | Not listed | Finished, full | $548,000 | n/a | 5-year-old roof, newer water heater |
| 253 Old Tassel Ct. | Active | 1996 | 2,878 | Finished, full | $490,000 | $170 | Newer HVAC components, Generac generator, remodeled kitchen and baths |
| 309 Horseshoe Bend | Active | 1994 | 2,158 | Unfinished | $489,900 | $227 | No specific updates listed |
| 414 Middle Valley Ln. | Active | 1993 | 2,448 | Finished, full | $449,900 | $184 | No specific updates listed |
| 602 Overhill Dr. | Active | 1993 | 1,680 | None | $439,900 | $262 | Updated kitchen and baths |
| 418 Middle Valley Ln. | Active | 1994 | 2,070 | None | $430,000 | $208 | New flooring, paint, gas stove |
These records span $275,000 within one subdivision, from $400,000 to $675,000. The newest house in the group is only four years younger than the oldest, so age does not explain the gap.
Why the per-foot number runs backward in Deer Run
Price per square foot is the quick way to compare houses, but in Deer Run it ranks the houses close to the reverse of their price.
The two most expensive houses that sold or went under contract this fall had the lowest per-foot figures. 512 Old Field Cove sold for $675,000, about $159 a square foot. 376 Yonah Circle went under contract at $544,000, about $137 a square foot. 602 Overhill Drive, the smallest house in the table with a listed size at 1,680 square feet, is asking about $262 a square foot, the highest figure in the group.
Every Deer Run house pays for the same things before its size counts at all: a lot in the same community, the same pools and courts, and the same drive to Towne Lake Parkway. A 1,680-square-foot house spreads that base over fewer feet. Extra square footage in a larger house adds to the price, but at a lower rate per foot than the base.
So a neighborhood average per square foot will flatter a small house and undersell a large one. If you are comparing Deer Run with another Towne Lake subdivision, compare houses of similar size. A blended per-foot figure mixes a 1,680-square-foot house with a 4,236-square-foot house and lands at a number that fits neither.
What the roof line in the remarks is worth
Once you set size aside, look at how the sellers wrote their remarks. Both fall closings named a roof. At 373 Yonah Circle, a 2,864-square-foot brick house with a finished basement, the remarks say "NEW ROOF!" and nothing else about systems. It closed at $490,000 on November 9. The 512 Old Field Cove listing lists a "recently replaced roof" along with updated front windows and exterior paint.
The summer sale on Dream Catcher Drive followed the same pattern. 4074 Dream Catcher Drive, a 1994 house recorded under the Deer Run North name, closed at $499,900 on July 31, 2026, and its remarks put a "1-year-old roof" first in the list of updates. On the active side, 4101 Dream Catcher Drive is asking $548,000. Its remarks name a "5-year-old 30-year architectural shingle roof and a newer water heater." 376 Yonah Circle lists Low-E insulated windows, a radiant barrier, added attic insulation and an architectural roof.
On a house built in 1994, a dated roof or HVAC system answers a buyer's first question before the inspection does. Two active listings, 309 Horseshoe Bend and 414 Middle Valley Lane, make no specific claims about updates or system ages. That doesn't mean the systems are original. It means a buyer will have to ask, and the answer could move the offer in either direction.
4035 Dream Catcher Drive is a one-owner stucco house with no basement. Its remarks name no system updates, yet it went under contract at $475,000, about $210 a square foot. Street, lot and upkeep still count. Replaced systems explain much of the spread, but not all of it.
What sits below the main floor
The other dividing line is underground. Every house in the table at $489,900 or above has a basement. 309 Horseshoe Bend's is unfinished. 512 Old Field Cove, 376 Yonah Circle, 4101 Dream Catcher Drive, 253 Old Tassel Court and 373 Yonah Circle all have finished ones. 4035 Dream Catcher Drive, at $475,000, is the only house without a basement priced above $440,000. The other two houses with no basement, 418 Middle Valley Lane and 602 Overhill Drive, are priced at $430,000 and $439,900.
The two houses from the opening fit here too. 617 Overhill Drive has a partial finished basement, and 420 Middle Valley Lane has a full unfinished one. So the $25,000 between them is not explained by basement space. The documented HVAC replacement is the clearest difference left.
Construction varies across these houses. This fall's records list brick, stucco, concrete, vinyl siding, and brick with wood siding. The $675,000 sale at 512 Old Field Cove is listed as stucco, and the $490,000 sale at 373 Yonah Circle is listed as brick. Front material alone doesn't set a price band here. Check the construction field on every listing you compare.
The fee, and the market around it
The annual association fee on most of these listings is $825. Others show $600 at 418 Middle Valley Lane, $830 at 309 Horseshoe Bend, $850 at 4101 Dream Catcher Drive and $900 at 420 Middle Valley Lane, all as reported on fall 2026 listings. According to the HOA's site, that fee goes toward a community with two pools, six pickleball courts, five tennis courts, two basketball courts, two playgrounds, a baseball field and three clubhouses that homeowners can rent. The fee has little effect on price differences inside Deer Run, because nearly every house pays about the same amount. It matters more when you compare Deer Run with another subdivision. These figures are general information drawn from listings, not legal, tax or financial advice, so confirm the current assessment and your own costs with the association and your own advisors before you commit.
The wider market gives buyers more room to sort houses this carefully than they had a few years ago. The Atlanta REALTORS® September 2026 Market Brief, built on FMLS data for 11 metro counties including Cherokee, reported September sales down 18.5% year over year, active listings up 6.7%, and a 4.9-month supply. With more inventory to choose from, a Deer Run house with dated systems competes against one down the street that already lists a new roof.
Quick answers
Are Deer Run and Deer Run North different markets? The MLS records some sales under the name "DEER RUN NORTH" and others under "Deer Run." The July sale at 4074 Dream Catcher Drive carried the North name. It showed the same $825 annual fee and the same 1990s build year as the houses filed under Deer Run. If you set a search alert, include both names, or you will miss listings.
Where do the lower-priced Deer Run houses land this year? 617 Overhill Drive went under contract at $400,000 this fall, and 615 Overhill Drive sold for the same $400,000 in March 2026. That listing named a new 2026 furnace and new granite counters. Both are roughly 2,000-square-foot houses.
Where does Deer Run sit relative to what's being built nearby? Deer Run is close to the Mill District work on Towne Lake Parkway, which we covered in our fall Towne Lake Parkway update. You can compare that location with any house in the table above.
If you're weighing two Deer Run houses with different roof dates, or you own one and want to know which of your past replacements will count with buyers, Broadus Realty Group can compare it against this fall's sales street by street. Start with a home valuation, or ask us what to fix before listing with our staging guidance.